“A vision, without the ability to execute, is probably a hallucination.” – Stephen M. Chase
One problem I deal with every summer is the numerous requests from students and parents for changes in science placement for the next school year. In the past, I generally denied most requests for moving students up to honors because I feel it is generally a bad idea. I still think it is a bad idea, but recently I have begun allowing the move, after voicing my concerns of course. My new policy is---move if you want, but accept the consequences of your bad decision. Two requests to move students into advanced placement chemistry are examples.
At the end of last semester I was informed that we were enrolling a transfer student from England for the next year. She was going to be a junior and wanted to take AP Chemistry; having finished the European equivalent of first year chemistry. My experience with exchange students has been that what European countries call chemistry is mostly a general science course that does not prepare students with enough background to succeed in AP. When the request came in I didn’t argue with the parent, just said OK and sent out a copy of my “summer homework” assignment consisting of 106 questions reviewing Honors Chemistry. I told the parent that a test would be given the second day of class covering the assignment and it would be the first grade of the quarter. The directions in the assignment clearly state that the student is expected to understand the material in the assignment on the first day of class, the material would not be re-taught. The parent and student saw what was expected and she dropped down to Honors Chemistry—where she should have been placed in the beginning.
The second student appears not to have been so smart about it. He took chemistry this summer at another school. Any reasonable person should realize that you can’t learn 38 weeks of chemistry in 6 weeks, and that the summer course could not be sufficient preparation for AP. I expressed my concerns but allowed it because the parents insisted. I sent out the same summer homework sheets, but the student did not drop. He showed up the first day of school with only half the work done. He just finished his test and got a 59%; the average grade being about 80%. His first grade will be an F and, since I am not going to re-teach the material he missed, may fail every test after. At some point he will either drop the class because he is failing or his parents will have to hire a tutor to help him catch up. Since he is on tuition assistance and probably can’t afford to hire a tutor the outcome will not be pretty. I have already decided not to say “I told you so!” when it happens. In real life, people learn from their mistakes, but smart people learn from others mistakes; and possibly in the future I will get more support and cooperation from guidance and the administration before things break bad. This is a very nice young man from what I can see from my dealings with him. He is polite, respectful, and hard working. All admirable qualities, but none of which translate into a solid background in chemistry.
One of the most regrettable things we tell a student is that they can do anything they want if they work hard enough. Of course this is a lie. No matter how hard I work I will never be an Olympic sprinter.
